Proposal 35 | Criminal Justice Reform
Criminal Justice Reform and Fair Sentencing Review Initiative
Purpose
To strengthen confidence in the justice system by ensuring sentences are proportionate and consistent, providing a structured way to review certain lengthy sentences after substantial time has been served, and improving the information available to policymakers and the public.
The Need
Public confidence depends on a system that treats similar conduct similarly, distinguishes among levels of culpability, and reserves its most severe penalties for the most serious offenses. Over time, changes in law and practice can produce wide disparities, and some individuals serve very long sentences under standards that have since been reconsidered. Without reliable data and orderly review mechanisms, policymakers cannot judge whether sentencing policy is achieving its purposes of accountability, deterrence, and public safety.
What This Proposal Does
- Establishes a structured, case-by-case review process for certain lengthy federal sentences after a substantial portion has been served, considering the offense, the person’s record and conduct while incarcerated, rehabilitation efforts, age and health, and public safety.
- Ensures review is a careful legal process — not automatic release — with notice to victims, opportunity for input, representation, and written findings by the deciding authority.
- Improves collection and public reporting of sentencing data so disparities, trends, and the effects of policy changes can be examined on a consistent basis.
- Supports research and pilot initiatives on evidence-based sentencing and supervision practices, including alternatives that maintain accountability for appropriate nonviolent cases.
- Encourages review of collateral consequences that may unnecessarily impede employment, housing, and family stability after a sentence is complete, while preserving restrictions genuinely needed for public safety.
Who It Helps
People subject to sentences that merit reconsideration under current standards, victims who deserve a transparent and respectful process, families affected by prolonged incarceration, and the broader public, which benefits from a system seen as fair and effective.
Implementation
The initiative would proceed through established judicial and administrative channels, with clear eligibility criteria, timelines, and procedural safeguards. Review bodies would require adequate staffing and training, and implementation would begin with careful attention to record completeness and victim notification.
Accountability and Results
The program would report the number of cases reviewed, decisions and reasoning in aggregate, outcomes for those released under review, and subsequent compliance with supervision. Data reporting would allow Congress to assess consistency, public safety outcomes, and whether review operates as intended.
Why Congress Should Act
Justice that is both firm and fair is a foundation of public trust and public safety. Congress can provide orderly mechanisms to correct disproportion, learn from reliable data, and keep the focus where it belongs: accountability for harm, protection of the public, and sentences that fit the offense and the person.
A proposal by Ruben Burgos, presented for consideration by Congress